Ukraine - International Brigade
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
I'm sure Farage, Fox, and the others who were saying how ready they were to man the barricades and fight to defend freedom, are busy putting their affairs in order so they can take this opportunity to do just that.
The first ten million years were the worst.
And the second ten million, they were the worst too.
And the second ten million, they were the worst too.
- Bird on a Fire
- Princess POW
- Posts: 10137
- Joined: Fri Oct 11, 2019 5:05 pm
- Location: Portugal
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Give them a minute, they're probably too busy moving their money around before the sanctions kick in.
We have the right to a clean, healthy, sustainable environment.
-
- After Pie
- Posts: 2029
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
I thought the ISIS wannabees were being prosecuted if they tried to return to the UK.EACLucifer wrote: ↑Tue Mar 01, 2022 6:45 amThey didn't use the foreign enlistment act against the scum that went to join ISIS, so it's pretty safe to assume it won't be used against people fighting against fascists invading a country we are arming.
Also, you have unanswered questions about China's mass detention and abuse of Uyghurs, coward.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Joining the foreign legion was illegal under the 1870 act, we just couldn't find any evidence (ditto fighting Franco). According to the wiki, the last successful prosecution occurred in 1896. This https://academic.oup.com/tcbh/article-a ... ogin=false says "the act proved embarrassingly unenforceable" and "a complete failure as a legal tool" in 1937, and the 1976 Diplock Report described the act as "antiquated"; I'm starting to think 1896 might keep its position as the last successful prosecution.
Apparently her department's own website was warning people could be prosecuted: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/ ... ght-russiascience_fox wrote: ↑Tue Mar 01, 2022 9:21 amWasn't Truss actively supporting the idea? - although she probably doesn't know what the laws actually are.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-60544838
I think it wouldn't have applied as ISIS weren't the army of a state - so that would be terror legislation that would be relevant?EACLucifer wrote: ↑Tue Mar 01, 2022 6:45 amThey didn't use the foreign enlistment act against the scum that went to join ISIS, so it's pretty safe to assume it won't be used against people fighting against fascists invading a country we are arming.
Also, you have unanswered questions about China's mass detention and abuse of Uyghurs, coward.
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Vict/33-34/90
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_E ... t_Act_1870
-
- After Pie
- Posts: 2029
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Does Tony Blair's cousin have a twitter feed, or Insta or TikTok or anything like that?
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
- shpalman
- Princess POW
- Posts: 8267
- Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 12:53 pm
- Location: One step beyond
- Contact:
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Not since he died of covid or whatever it was.Herainestold wrote: ↑Tue Mar 01, 2022 4:23 pmDoes Tony Blair's cousin have a twitter feed, or Insta or TikTok or anything like that?
having that swing is a necessary but not sufficient condition for it meaning a thing
@shpalman@mastodon.me.uk
@shpalman@mastodon.me.uk
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
The first ten million years were the worst.
And the second ten million, they were the worst too.
And the second ten million, they were the worst too.
- EACLucifer
- Stummy Beige
- Posts: 4177
- Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2019 7:49 am
- Location: In Sumerian Haze
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Reading about a lot of people going, and from a lot of places. Saw a report saying two hundred from the Netherlands - not all of them Dutch - and another saying fifty from Japan. Saw an interview with an IDF Givati Brigade veteran, and the description strongly suggested more than just one was present, but I don't have Hebrew, so couldn't confirm.
Also a lot of Americans look like they are going, veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan. The numbers are high enough that some are apparently forming into platoons and going in groups.
ETA: There's also Free Syrians talking about trying to get there, including a tank-hunting ace nicknamed "Abu TOW"
2ETA: Also some Iraqi Kurds already fighting, along with Tatars. Not sure if they were living in Ukraine before the invasion or not.
Also a lot of Americans look like they are going, veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan. The numbers are high enough that some are apparently forming into platoons and going in groups.
ETA: There's also Free Syrians talking about trying to get there, including a tank-hunting ace nicknamed "Abu TOW"
2ETA: Also some Iraqi Kurds already fighting, along with Tatars. Not sure if they were living in Ukraine before the invasion or not.
Last edited by EACLucifer on Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:21 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- After Pie
- Posts: 2029
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Under the Geneva convention do free lance mercenaries have any protection or can the Russians summarily execute them if captured?
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
- Woodchopper
- Princess POW
- Posts: 7078
- Joined: Sat Oct 12, 2019 9:05 am
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
They have the same protections as any other people serving in a national army. Summary execution isn't allowed under any circumstances.Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:20 amUnder the Geneva convention do free lance mercenaries have any protection or can the Russians summarily execute them if captured?
-
- Snowbonk
- Posts: 551
- Joined: Wed Nov 13, 2019 12:42 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Not that Russia seems to care that much about the Geneva convention at the moment.Woodchopper wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 7:22 amThey have the same protections as any other people serving in a national army. Summary execution isn't allowed under any circumstances.Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:20 amUnder the Geneva convention do free lance mercenaries have any protection or can the Russians summarily execute them if captured?
-
- After Pie
- Posts: 2029
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Woodchopper wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 7:22 amThey have the same protections as any other people serving in a national army. Summary execution isn't allowed under any circumstances.Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:20 amUnder the Geneva convention do free lance mercenaries have any protection or can the Russians summarily execute them if captured?
Thanks. I am a bit surprised by that, but so be it.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
You are surprised that the Geneva convention gives mercenaries the same fundamental rights it gives all, stuff like a fair trial and humane treatment!?Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 2:49 pmWoodchopper wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 7:22 amThey have the same protections as any other people serving in a national army. Summary execution isn't allowed under any circumstances.Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:20 amUnder the Geneva convention do free lance mercenaries have any protection or can the Russians summarily execute them if captured?
Thanks. I am a bit surprised by that, but so be it.
-
- After Pie
- Posts: 2029
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Yes. I can remember reading about summary execution for commandos etc in previous conflicts. I think they have to have some kind of insignia to indicate they are combatants.monkey wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 3:23 pmYou are surprised that the Geneva convention gives mercenaries the same fundamental rights it gives all, stuff like a fair trial and humane treatment!?Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 2:49 pmWoodchopper wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 7:22 am
They have the same protections as any other people serving in a national army. Summary execution isn't allowed under any circumstances.
Thanks. I am a bit surprised by that, but so be it.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
POWs have been mistreated and killed in the past. Do you think that the GC does not protect them?Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 3:32 pmYes. I can remember reading about summary execution for commandos etc in previous conflicts. I think they have to have some kind of insignia to indicate they are combatants.
-
- After Pie
- Posts: 2029
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
So much depends on the country holding them. I wasn't sure if the Geneva convention protected mercenaries but apparently it does. Not sure I would trust Putin's men though.monkey wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:13 pmPOWs have been mistreated and killed in the past. Do you think that the GC does not protect them?Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 3:32 pmYes. I can remember reading about summary execution for commandos etc in previous conflicts. I think they have to have some kind of insignia to indicate they are combatants.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
- Bird on a Fire
- Princess POW
- Posts: 10137
- Joined: Fri Oct 11, 2019 5:05 pm
- Location: Portugal
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
I'll cop to not being entirely sure either, fwiw. I know the use of mercenaries and "contractors", including e.g. by the west in Afghanistan and Iraq, was partly to circumvent certain international agreements, but without being sure of the details I wasn't sure if both rights and responsibilities differ, or just the rights. Presumably mercenaries are categorised as combatants rather than civilians, but could be POWs?monkey wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 3:23 pmYou are surprised that the Geneva convention gives mercenaries the same fundamental rights it gives all, stuff like a fair trial and humane treatment!?Herainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 2:49 pmWoodchopper wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 7:22 am
They have the same protections as any other people serving in a national army. Summary execution isn't allowed under any circumstances.
Thanks. I am a bit surprised by that, but so be it.
We have the right to a clean, healthy, sustainable environment.
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
You don't have to know what the legal status of mercenaries is to know that the Convention has fundamental protections for everyone in a conflict.Bird on a Fire wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:20 pmI'll cop to not being entirely sure either, fwiw. I know the use of mercenaries and "contractors", including e.g. by the west in Afghanistan and Iraq, was partly to circumvent certain international agreements, but without being sure of the details I wasn't sure if both rights and responsibilities differ, or just the rights. Presumably mercenaries are categorised as combatants rather than civilians, but could be POWs?
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Here's a summary about international law on mercenaries by doctors without borders - clicky
That might clear things up (or not, it seems confusing to me and country dependentent), but you will note it includes this bit - "They are entitled to the fundamental guarantees established for all individuals."
That might clear things up (or not, it seems confusing to me and country dependentent), but you will note it includes this bit - "They are entitled to the fundamental guarantees established for all individuals."
- Bird on a Fire
- Princess POW
- Posts: 10137
- Joined: Fri Oct 11, 2019 5:05 pm
- Location: Portugal
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Ah - I was unsure about the "same protections as any other people serving in a national army" bit. Obviously nobody is allowed to execute captives, no.monkey wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:26 pmYou don't have to know what the legal status of mercenaries is to know that the Convention has fundamental protections for everyone in a conflict.Bird on a Fire wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:20 pmI'll cop to not being entirely sure either, fwiw. I know the use of mercenaries and "contractors", including e.g. by the west in Afghanistan and Iraq, was partly to circumvent certain international agreements, but without being sure of the details I wasn't sure if both rights and responsibilities differ, or just the rights. Presumably mercenaries are categorised as combatants rather than civilians, but could be POWs?
The DWB link you give says "If arrested, mercenaries are not entitled to the status of prisoners of war" and also
which is a difference from national armies. (It also says that military contractors don't count as mercenaries, so I was wrong to conflate them).Mercenaries are not entitled to the status of combatant, prisoner of war (API Article 47), or any of the categories of protected persons provided for by the Geneva Conventions, unless they are wounded or sick, although they must always benefit from humane treatment.
So they're not specifically protected by the Geneva Convention as combatants would be, but you still can't shoot them after you capture them and must be humane in general. I assume you can kill them instead of capturing them, though?
We have the right to a clean, healthy, sustainable environment.
- Bird on a Fire
- Princess POW
- Posts: 10137
- Joined: Fri Oct 11, 2019 5:05 pm
- Location: Portugal
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
More to the point, perhaps, is that the legal definition of mercenary is quite tight, and probably wouldn't cover International Brigades (my bold):
Seems more likely anyone joining a "Ukrainian foreign legion" or similar would be a regular combatant with full Geneva protection (including that you can't shoot them after capture).
I've not seen any mention of the salary involved nor how it compares to the regular Ukrainian forces, but AFAICT people are joining because they're motivated to help defend Ukraine from Russian incursion, rather than for the money.As defined by Article 47 of Additional Protocol I to the Geneva Conventions, a mercenary is any person who:
is specially recruited locally or abroad,
does, in fact, participate directly in the hostilities,
is motivated to take part in the hostilities essentially by the desire for private gain and, in fact, is promised, by or on behalf of a party to the conflict, material compensation substantially in excess of that promised or paid to combatants of similar ranks and functions in the armed forces of that party
is neither a national of a party to the conflict nor a resident of a territory controlled by a party to the conflict;
is not a member of the armed forces of a party to the conflict; and
has not been sent by a State that is not a party to the conflict on official duty as a member of its armed forces.
Seems more likely anyone joining a "Ukrainian foreign legion" or similar would be a regular combatant with full Geneva protection (including that you can't shoot them after capture).
We have the right to a clean, healthy, sustainable environment.
- Woodchopper
- Princess POW
- Posts: 7078
- Joined: Sat Oct 12, 2019 9:05 am
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
There is a distinction between a mercenary and a foreign citizen who joins a state's armed forces. As far as I know and as Bird points out we've been discussing the former in terms of foreigners who have signed up to fight for Ukraine. Similarly, the Ghurkas or other commonwealth citizens serving in the UK armed forces aren't mercenaries in a legal sense, nor are members of the French Foreign Legion.
Also, when citing the Geneva Conventions etc be aware that people are also covered by International Human Rights Law. So, to take the earlier example, summarily executing a prisoner would be a grave violation of human rights regardless of their nationality or status as a mercenary.
Also, when citing the Geneva Conventions etc be aware that people are also covered by International Human Rights Law. So, to take the earlier example, summarily executing a prisoner would be a grave violation of human rights regardless of their nationality or status as a mercenary.
-
- After Pie
- Posts: 2029
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
The media would have me think that there are some retired British servicemen that have been recruited by somebody to go into Ukraine right now.
So, in general, they would be protected, but as mercenaries would not get the full protection accorded to Ukranian armed forces POWs. Still Putin's men can't shoot them.
https://londonlovesbusiness.com/former- ... desperate/
So, in general, they would be protected, but as mercenaries would not get the full protection accorded to Ukranian armed forces POWs. Still Putin's men can't shoot them.
I don't give this source a lot of credibility.An unnamed private military firm based in Europe are to fund the SAS operation in Ukraine which is a clever plan as it is does not involve the British military directly.
More than a dozen SAS veterans are now on the ground in Ukraine and more are to travel to the country later this week.
https://londonlovesbusiness.com/former- ... desperate/
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
- Stranger Mouse
- After Pie
- Posts: 2390
- Joined: Sat Dec 21, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
If they are SAS veterans it is not an SAS operation anywayHerainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 5:26 pmThe media would have me think that there are some retired British servicemen that have been recruited by somebody to go into Ukraine right now.
So, in general, they would be protected, but as mercenaries would not get the full protection accorded to Ukranian armed forces POWs. Still Putin's men can't shoot them.
I don't give this source a lot of credibility.An unnamed private military firm based in Europe are to fund the SAS operation in Ukraine which is a clever plan as it is does not involve the British military directly.
More than a dozen SAS veterans are now on the ground in Ukraine and more are to travel to the country later this week.
https://londonlovesbusiness.com/former- ... desperate/
I’ve decided I should be on the pardon list if that’s still in the works
-
- After Pie
- Posts: 2029
- Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm
Re: Ukraine - International Brigade
Yes. The story presents it as such, but they would just be common or garden variety mercenariesStranger Mouse wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 6:12 pmIf they are SAS veterans it is not an SAS operation anywayHerainestold wrote: ↑Wed Mar 02, 2022 5:26 pmThe media would have me think that there are some retired British servicemen that have been recruited by somebody to go into Ukraine right now.
So, in general, they would be protected, but as mercenaries would not get the full protection accorded to Ukranian armed forces POWs. Still Putin's men can't shoot them.
I don't give this source a lot of credibility.An unnamed private military firm based in Europe are to fund the SAS operation in Ukraine which is a clever plan as it is does not involve the British military directly.
More than a dozen SAS veterans are now on the ground in Ukraine and more are to travel to the country later this week.
https://londonlovesbusiness.com/former- ... desperate/
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again