Ukraine - International Brigade

Discussions about serious topics, for serious people
User avatar
Bird on a Fire
Princess POW
Posts: 10137
Joined: Fri Oct 11, 2019 5:05 pm
Location: Portugal

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Bird on a Fire » Wed Mar 02, 2022 8:30 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 7:58 pm
Yes. The story presents it as such, but they would just be common or garden variety mercenaries
Probably not, actually - see the definition of mercenary in my post above (LFM).
We have the right to a clean, healthy, sustainable environment.

User avatar
Sciolus
Dorkwood
Posts: 1313
Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 6:42 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Sciolus » Wed Mar 02, 2022 10:54 pm

Bush also invented the category of Unlawful Combatant, which might apply:
The term “unlawful combatant” is used to refer to an individual who belongs to an armed group, in a context where either the individual or the group do not fulfil the conditions for combatant status. The term was employed by the administration of President George W. Bush of the United States in its ‘global war on terror’ to describe persons who are, in its view, neither combatants nor civilians but belong to a third category of persons who can be attacked at any time and can be detained indefinitely without trial. It is also sometimes used as a synonym for “unprivileged belligerent”.
https://casebook.icrc.org/glossary/unlawful-combatants
But that's not recognised under international law. As if Putin would care.
The assumption that unlawful combatant status exists as a separate category to lawful combatant and civilian is contradicted by the findings of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia in the Celebici Judgment. The judgment quoted the 1958 International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) commentary on the Fourth Geneva Convention: "Every person in enemy hands must be either a prisoner of war and, as such, be covered by the Third Convention; or a civilian covered by the Fourth Convention. There is no intermediate status; nobody in enemy hands can be outside the law".[6]
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unlawful_combatant

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Wed Mar 02, 2022 11:51 pm

Bird on a Fire wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 8:30 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 7:58 pm
Yes. The story presents it as such, but they would just be common or garden variety mercenaries
Probably not, actually - see the definition of mercenary in my post above (LFM).
What do you mean?
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

User avatar
dyqik
Princess POW
Posts: 7527
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2019 4:19 pm
Location: Masshole
Contact:

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by dyqik » Thu Mar 03, 2022 1:23 am

Herainestold wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 11:51 pm
Bird on a Fire wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 8:30 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 7:58 pm
Yes. The story presents it as such, but they would just be common or garden variety mercenaries
Probably not, actually - see the definition of mercenary in my post above (LFM).
What do you mean?
Probably he means the words that you can see if you click on the underlined letters.

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Thu Mar 03, 2022 1:29 am

dyqik wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 1:23 am
Herainestold wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 11:51 pm
Bird on a Fire wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 8:30 pm

Probably not, actually - see the definition of mercenary in my post above (LFM).
What do you mean?
Probably he means the words that you can see if you click on the underlined letters.
I get that. It gives a definition of mercenary that would seem to apply to the SAS guys mentioned in the article. Bird on a Fire says it doesn't.
I don't see how it doesn't.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

Millennie Al
After Pie
Posts: 1621
Joined: Mon Mar 16, 2020 4:02 am

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Millennie Al » Thu Mar 03, 2022 4:32 am

Herainestold wrote:
Wed Mar 02, 2022 4:20 am
Under the Geneva convention do free lance mercenaries have any protection or can the Russians summarily execute them if captured?
No, and yes (though there may be protection for other reasons). From
PROTOCOL ADDITIONAL
TO THE GENEVA CONVENTIONS OF 12 AUGUST 1949,
AND RELATING TO THE PROTECTION
OF VICTIMS OF INTERNATIONAL ARMED CONFLICTS
(PROTOCOL I), OF 8 JUNE 1977
available at https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/i ... P-I-EN.pdf

Article 47 — Mercenaries

1. A mercenary shall not have the right to be a combatant or a prisoner of war.

User avatar
TopBadger
Catbabel
Posts: 782
Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 6:33 pm
Location: Halfway up

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by TopBadger » Thu Mar 03, 2022 11:47 am

AIUI the people volunteering to fight aren't going on a payroll and therefore aren't mercenaries...
You can't polish a turd...
unless its Lion or Osterich poo... http://dsc.discovery.com/videos/mythbus ... -turd.html

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Thu Mar 03, 2022 2:28 pm

TopBadger wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 11:47 am
AIUI the people volunteering to fight aren't going on a payroll and therefore aren't mercenaries...
Most of them are not.
I was curious about the former SAS members recruited by a private company to go into Ukraine.
They are private contractors rather than mercenaries. What happens to them if they are captured. They would not be POWs.
I presume they would be criminals under Russian law.
It is understood the operation will be funded by an unnamed European country via a private military company.
https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/15 ... en-wallace
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

User avatar
Woodchopper
Princess POW
Posts: 7057
Joined: Sat Oct 12, 2019 9:05 am

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Woodchopper » Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:11 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 2:28 pm
TopBadger wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 11:47 am
AIUI the people volunteering to fight aren't going on a payroll and therefore aren't mercenaries...
Most of them are not.
I was curious about the former SAS members recruited by a private company to go into Ukraine.
They are private contractors rather than mercenaries. What happens to them if they are captured. They would not be POWs.
I presume they would be criminals under Russian law.
It is understood the operation will be funded by an unnamed European country via a private military company.
https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/15 ... en-wallace
It depends what they are doing in Ukraine, and the article isn't clear. If they aren't taking part in combat and are playing an ancillary role, for example providing training a long way from the battlefield, then legally speaking they're just civilians who are working for a private company.

User avatar
dyqik
Princess POW
Posts: 7527
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2019 4:19 pm
Location: Masshole
Contact:

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by dyqik » Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:21 pm

Woodchopper wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:11 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 2:28 pm
TopBadger wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 11:47 am
AIUI the people volunteering to fight aren't going on a payroll and therefore aren't mercenaries...
Most of them are not.
I was curious about the former SAS members recruited by a private company to go into Ukraine.
They are private contractors rather than mercenaries. What happens to them if they are captured. They would not be POWs.
I presume they would be criminals under Russian law.
It is understood the operation will be funded by an unnamed European country via a private military company.
https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/15 ... en-wallace
It depends what they are doing in Ukraine, and the article isn't clear. If they aren't taking part in combat and are playing an ancillary role, for example providing training a long way from the battlefield, then legally speaking they're just civilians who are working for a private company.
And since Ukraine is not Russia, Russian law is legally irrelevant.

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:25 pm

Woodchopper wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:11 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 2:28 pm
TopBadger wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 11:47 am
AIUI the people volunteering to fight aren't going on a payroll and therefore aren't mercenaries...
Most of them are not.
I was curious about the former SAS members recruited by a private company to go into Ukraine.
They are private contractors rather than mercenaries. What happens to them if they are captured. They would not be POWs.
I presume they would be criminals under Russian law.
It is understood the operation will be funded by an unnamed European country via a private military company.
https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/15 ... en-wallace
It depends what they are doing in Ukraine, and the article isn't clear. If they aren't taking part in combat and are playing an ancillary role, for example providing training a long way from the battlefield, then legally speaking they're just civilians who are working for a private company.
Thanks.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:26 pm

dyqik wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:21 pm
Woodchopper wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:11 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 2:28 pm


Most of them are not.
I was curious about the former SAS members recruited by a private company to go into Ukraine.
They are private contractors rather than mercenaries. What happens to them if they are captured. They would not be POWs.
I presume they would be criminals under Russian law.



https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/15 ... en-wallace
It depends what they are doing in Ukraine, and the article isn't clear. If they aren't taking part in combat and are playing an ancillary role, for example providing training a long way from the battlefield, then legally speaking they're just civilians who are working for a private company.
And since Ukraine is not Russia, Russian law is legally irrelevant.
If the Russians catch them, I can assure you they will not be applying Ukranian law. They may not be applying any law at all.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

User avatar
Stranger Mouse
After Pie
Posts: 2347
Joined: Sat Dec 21, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Stranger Mouse » Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:37 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:26 pm
dyqik wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:21 pm
Woodchopper wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:11 pm


It depends what they are doing in Ukraine, and the article isn't clear. If they aren't taking part in combat and are playing an ancillary role, for example providing training a long way from the battlefield, then legally speaking they're just civilians who are working for a private company.
And since Ukraine is not Russia, Russian law is legally irrelevant.
If the Russians catch them, I can assure you they will not be applying Ukranian law. They may not be applying any law at all.
If you believe the Russians won’t be applying any law at all I am confused as to why you think Unkraine would be safe in surrendering their people to Russian forces.
I’ve decided I should be on the pardon list if that’s still in the works

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:40 pm

Stranger Mouse wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:37 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:26 pm
dyqik wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:21 pm

And since Ukraine is not Russia, Russian law is legally irrelevant.
If the Russians catch them, I can assure you they will not be applying Ukranian law. They may not be applying any law at all.
If you believe the Russians won’t be applying any law at all I am confused as to why you think Unkraine would be safe in surrendering their people to Russian forces.
Better red than dead, as my pa used to say.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:42 pm

I'm just trying to figure out the nuances of mercenaries/contracters with respect to law in a conflict zone, Ukraine.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

User avatar
Stranger Mouse
After Pie
Posts: 2347
Joined: Sat Dec 21, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Stranger Mouse » Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:47 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:40 pm
Stranger Mouse wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:37 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:26 pm


If the Russians catch them, I can assure you they will not be applying Ukranian law. They may not be applying any law at all.
If you believe the Russians won’t be applying any law at all I am confused as to why you think Unkraine would be safe in surrendering their people to Russian forces.
Better red than dead, as my pa used to say.
I don’t understand. You have made very clear at every point that you believe that Ukraine should surrender for safety reasons but you have also just stated that you believe Russia may choose not to follow any law at all in how they treat people. How are these views consistent? And what has “better red than dead” got to do with anything when we are discussing whether Russia will decide to ignore any law whatsoever in their treatment of prisoners.
I’ve decided I should be on the pardon list if that’s still in the works

tom p
After Pie
Posts: 1876
Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 1:14 pm
Location: the low countries

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by tom p » Thu Mar 03, 2022 4:11 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:42 pm
I'm just trying to figure out the nuances of mercenaries/contracters with respect to law in a conflict zone, Ukraine.
Well why don't you f.ck off for a bit and do some reading, rather than making stupid statements and asking stupid questions?
seriously, links have already been provided. read them and understand them. Read them. And understand them.

I disagree with the people who have ordered you to stop trolling, but if you really mean what you say, then actually bother to read up on it.

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Thu Mar 03, 2022 4:59 pm

tom p wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 4:11 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:42 pm
I'm just trying to figure out the nuances of mercenaries/contracters with respect to law in a conflict zone, Ukraine.
Well why don't you f.ck off for a bit and do some reading, rather than making stupid statements and asking stupid questions?
seriously, links have already been provided. read them and understand them. Read them. And understand them.

I disagree with the people who have ordered you to stop trolling, but if you really mean what you say, then actually bother to read up on it.
I have read it and there are lots of gray areas and contradictions. By asking questions and getting replies from people you can start to get an idea
of the complexities of this.

If we are encouraging people to go and fight in Ukraine, as volunteers or as contractors or as mercenaries, maybe we should think through the consequences, what happens when they are captured by the Russians, what laws apply, and are the Russians likely to apply them or apply their own or act arbitrarily?

This could be a discussion, not just reading regulations. I guess people don't want to discuss it. So be it.
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

Herainestold
After Pie
Posts: 2029
Joined: Mon Nov 25, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Herainestold » Thu Mar 03, 2022 5:07 pm

Stranger Mouse wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:47 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:40 pm
Stranger Mouse wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:37 pm


If you believe the Russians won’t be applying any law at all I am confused as to why you think Unkraine would be safe in surrendering their people to Russian forces.
Better red than dead, as my pa used to say.
I don’t understand. You have made very clear at every point that you believe that Ukraine should surrender for safety reasons but you have also just stated that you believe Russia may choose not to follow any law at all in how they treat people. How are these views consistent? And what has “better red than dead” got to do with anything when we are discussing whether Russia will decide to ignore any law whatsoever in their treatment of prisoners.
I don't know what I think. People's views can change. One of the ways they change is by discussing things and reading other people's thoughts.
We are in a horrible place right now with no easy options. I am not sure that encouraging Ukranians to die and destroy their country really helps anybody. I don't know what Russia is going to do. What do think they will do? How do you see this playing out?
Masking forever
Putin is a monster.
Russian socialism will rise again

User avatar
Stranger Mouse
After Pie
Posts: 2347
Joined: Sat Dec 21, 2019 1:23 pm

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Stranger Mouse » Thu Mar 03, 2022 5:28 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 5:07 pm
Stranger Mouse wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:47 pm
Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:40 pm


Better red than dead, as my pa used to say.
I don’t understand. You have made very clear at every point that you believe that Ukraine should surrender for safety reasons but you have also just stated that you believe Russia may choose not to follow any law at all in how they treat people. How are these views consistent? And what has “better red than dead” got to do with anything when we are discussing whether Russia will decide to ignore any law whatsoever in their treatment of prisoners.
I don't know what I think. People's views can change. One of the ways they change is by discussing things and reading other people's thoughts.
We are in a horrible place right now with no easy options. I am not sure that encouraging Ukranians to die and destroy their country really helps anybody. I don't know what Russia is going to do. What do think they will do? How do you see this playing out?
I don’t know. But what I do know is that absolutely nobody on any of the Ukraine threads is encouraging Ukrainian people to do anything. Any suggestion they are is a lie. I did searches on all the threads and then checked manually for any post that could be interpreted as doing this. There are none. Absolutely none.

Stop lying.
I’ve decided I should be on the pardon list if that’s still in the works

User avatar
Opti
Dorkwood
Posts: 1473
Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 11:21 pm
Location: On the beach

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by Opti » Thu Mar 03, 2022 5:34 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 5:07 pm

[snip]
I don't know what I think. People's views can change. One of the ways they change is by discussing things and reading other people's thoughts.
Still not changed your mind about China, eh? Sometimes you do know what you think.
Time for a big fat one.

WFJ
Catbabel
Posts: 648
Joined: Tue Jun 01, 2021 7:54 am

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by WFJ » Thu Mar 03, 2022 5:34 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 4:59 pm
If we are encouraging people to go and fight in Ukraine, as volunteers or as contractors or as mercenaries, maybe we should think through the consequences, what happens when they are captured by the Russians, what laws apply, and are the Russians likely to apply them or apply their own or act arbitrarily?
It is irrelevant.

International law does not apply to Russia, US and China, nor, if they so choose, to those they are directly working with or otherwise protecting (UK, Israel, Belarus maybe). All that matters in these cases are the political repercussions of their actions. Externally, Putin has shown he does not care about western political views, China won't care, and unless things are very bad India probably won't take a strong view, and has much less power anyway. Internally, at least the US/UK face some political pressures to act responsibly, but in Russia there is much less.

User avatar
TopBadger
Catbabel
Posts: 782
Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 6:33 pm
Location: Halfway up

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by TopBadger » Thu Mar 03, 2022 5:35 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 3:40 pm
Better red than dead, as my pa used to say.
Makes me wonder if cowardice is learned or inherited...

I'm pleased there are Ukrainians willing to fight to defend their country. Afghanistan would be a better place if its Army stood and fought the Taliban.
You can't polish a turd...
unless its Lion or Osterich poo... http://dsc.discovery.com/videos/mythbus ... -turd.html

User avatar
jdc
Hilda Ogden
Posts: 1925
Joined: Wed Sep 25, 2019 4:31 pm
Location: Your Mum

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by jdc » Thu Mar 03, 2022 6:28 pm

Herainestold wrote:
Thu Mar 03, 2022 5:07 pm

I don't know what I think.
You think that NATO are to blame for the conflict, that the West should have no involvement in Ukraine, that there should be a Slavic sphere of influence, and that it's reasonable for Putin to decide Ukraine should be within that sphere. You hope that Ukraine will surrender, and give Putin an easy victory.

hth

User avatar
EACLucifer
Stummy Beige
Posts: 4177
Joined: Fri Dec 13, 2019 7:49 am
Location: In Sumerian Haze

Re: Ukraine - International Brigade

Post by EACLucifer » Thu Mar 03, 2022 11:55 pm

Ukrainian officials reporting sixteen thousand joining up this way.

Any chance something similar can be set up for former military pilots, along with all the combat planes they can carry?

Post Reply