Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Discussions about serious topics, for serious people
Post Reply
Tristan
Fuzzable
Posts: 305
Joined: Tue Aug 30, 2022 12:53 pm

Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Post by Tristan » Thu Nov 28, 2024 1:06 pm

Yesterday Tahir Ali asked whether the government would commit to banning the desecration of religious texts and prophets of Abrahamic religions: https://x.com/TahirAliMP/status/1861765654178640014

We got rid of blasphemy laws in this country and this is an attempt to get them back on the books.

Starmer's response was weak. Why couldn't he give a firm "No it won't" ?

IvanV
Stummy Beige
Posts: 3059
Joined: Mon May 17, 2021 11:12 am

Re: Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Post by IvanV » Sun Dec 01, 2024 4:31 pm

I found a moment to listen to the recording before responding.

We already have laws against religious hate crime. So there is no need for a specific law on desecration. If desecration is a hate crime, it's already illegal. And we know how blasphemy/desecration laws can be abused. So let's just stick with the sensible law. I would doubtless have said that if I had to answer such a question.

But Starmer didn't say that. He condemned Islamophobia and desecration, which might be politically useful. Maybe it is better to keep these people onside not to actually say you won't do what they want. They probably know that hateful desecration is already illegal, and want the illiberality of the desecration law. So maybe Starmer is actually a better politician than me, in these polarised times. Right wingers might be more likely to give Ali what he wants. Better not to push him into the arms of the right wingers over one issue.

User avatar
bob sterman
Dorkwood
Posts: 1228
Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:25 pm
Location: Location Location

Re: Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Post by bob sterman » Sun Dec 01, 2024 9:20 pm

In addition to "desecration of religious texts" he also wants to prohibit "targeted vilification of all the prophets of the Abrahamic faiths."

Does this count as vilification of prophets?

Image

noggins
Catbabel
Posts: 630
Joined: Wed Nov 13, 2019 1:30 pm

Re: Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Post by noggins » Sun Dec 01, 2024 10:27 pm

Or
Image

IvanV
Stummy Beige
Posts: 3059
Joined: Mon May 17, 2021 11:12 am

Re: Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Post by IvanV » Mon Dec 02, 2024 9:24 am

Indeed. That's exactly what's wrong with specific blasphemy, desecration, vilification laws. Ali makes it look like he is asking for a law against religious hate crime, which we already have, and is hard to disagree with. But in effect in asking for those specific laws, we can surmise he might be an illiberal bigot who understands perfectly well what he is asking for. Whilst it might have been enjoyable to hear Starmer saying, in effect, shut up you illiberal bigot, maybe he did well to agree with being opposed to religious hate crime, and avoid saying that, which might not have gone down very well. The alternative would have been to say to him, I'm sure you aren't an illiberal bigot, so it would be a bad idea to have these specific laws that enable illiberal bigotry, and lets stay with the religious hate crime laws we already have, which already outlaw the things of this nature that should be outlawed.

I'm just offering this as an idea, I don't know if even I agree with it, and would be interested in other's thoughts.

User avatar
Trinucleus
Dorkwood
Posts: 1061
Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 6:45 pm

Re: Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Post by Trinucleus » Mon Dec 02, 2024 9:27 am

bob sterman wrote:
Sun Dec 01, 2024 9:20 pm
In addition to "desecration of religious texts" he also wants to prohibit "targeted vilification of all the prophets of the Abrahamic faiths."

Does this count as vilification of prophets?

Image
No, because Brian wasn't a prophet, he was a very naughty boy

philbo
Clardic Fug
Posts: 170
Joined: Sun Feb 23, 2020 11:06 am

Re: Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Post by philbo » Mon Dec 02, 2024 10:55 am

If you believe in an all-powerful God, why do your holy books, prophets, etc. need legal protection?

I've always seen blasphemy laws as one of the strongest bits of evidence that the sort of god the Abrahamic religions worship does not exist.

User avatar
Martin Y
Stummy Beige
Posts: 3213
Joined: Mon Nov 11, 2019 1:08 pm

Re: Blasphemy - desecration of religious texts

Post by Martin Y » Mon Dec 02, 2024 2:57 pm

Ah, well, the Almighty was working through that lynch mob.

Post Reply