Is this good science or pseudoscience? (Food intolerances)
Posted: Mon Aug 03, 2020 7:47 pm
I’ve just been advertised Foodmarble on Facebook, it’s a gadget that claims to help you find out about food intolerances.
https://foodmarble.com/
I thought that rather than dismiss it and move on I would do the properly skeptical thing and try to read the website first. It seems that the device measures hydrogen in the breath as an indicator of how much fermentation is happening in your gut. This is, as they claim, “Based on validated clinical technology.”
“Based on” is a bit a phrase I’m always suspicious of. They have conducted what seem from the abstracts to be proper trials, linked to from here: https://foodmarble.com/how-it-works
It seems like their gadget does perform similarly well to a bench top tester, and could therefore be used to perform diagnostic tests with some degree of confidence, although I’m not experienced in reading papers. However when I look at what hospitals do for these tests, they are normally conducted after a fast (amongst other conditions), which I don’t think is the case here. See for example: https://www.hey.nhs.uk/patient-leaflet/ ... eath-test/
(Incidentally I found that leaflet after following a link from their FAQ, https://help.foodmarble.com/en/articles ... t-used-for, 2nd link in the article, which it turns out is actually a google search!)
I suspect the detail of methodology is quite important and is the difference between a lifestyle test and a proper medical test, never mind if the equipment itself works just as well. If you succeed in making kit smaller and more affordable why stop at selling it to medical people who will use it properly? Why not sell it to anyone who can afford it and become part of the Wellness sector? Maybe I’m stepping past skepticism and becoming cynical.
https://foodmarble.com/
I thought that rather than dismiss it and move on I would do the properly skeptical thing and try to read the website first. It seems that the device measures hydrogen in the breath as an indicator of how much fermentation is happening in your gut. This is, as they claim, “Based on validated clinical technology.”
“Based on” is a bit a phrase I’m always suspicious of. They have conducted what seem from the abstracts to be proper trials, linked to from here: https://foodmarble.com/how-it-works
It seems like their gadget does perform similarly well to a bench top tester, and could therefore be used to perform diagnostic tests with some degree of confidence, although I’m not experienced in reading papers. However when I look at what hospitals do for these tests, they are normally conducted after a fast (amongst other conditions), which I don’t think is the case here. See for example: https://www.hey.nhs.uk/patient-leaflet/ ... eath-test/
(Incidentally I found that leaflet after following a link from their FAQ, https://help.foodmarble.com/en/articles ... t-used-for, 2nd link in the article, which it turns out is actually a google search!)
I suspect the detail of methodology is quite important and is the difference between a lifestyle test and a proper medical test, never mind if the equipment itself works just as well. If you succeed in making kit smaller and more affordable why stop at selling it to medical people who will use it properly? Why not sell it to anyone who can afford it and become part of the Wellness sector? Maybe I’m stepping past skepticism and becoming cynical.