Preprint server removes ‘inflammatory’ papers in superconductor controversy
This is about that business of high-pressure room-temperature superconductors (i.e. "we got them to work at room temperature we only need a huge pressure to do it") as opposed to normal-'pressure low-temperature superconductors (i.e. "we got them to work at normal pressure we only need a low temperature to do it"). The low temperature is probably easier but yeah, room-temperature superconductors, if you believe the results, which there are obviously some who don't.
Superconductivity fight
Superconductivity fight
molto tricky
Re: Superconductivity fight
The temperature of superconductivity was a hot topic back in the 90’s when I was learning about it. Terrible straight-line extrapolation from essentially 2 groups of data points to show how it was all but inevitable that we would get room temperature superconductivity sometime soon. Motivated reasoning in abundance.shpalman wrote: ↑Thu Mar 17, 2022 9:00 amPreprint server removes ‘inflammatory’ papers in superconductor controversy
This is about that business of high-pressure room-temperature superconductors (i.e. "we got them to work at room temperature we only need a huge pressure to do it") as opposed to normal-'pressure low-temperature superconductors (i.e. "we got them to work at normal pressure we only need a low temperature to do it"). The low temperature is probably easier but yeah, room-temperature superconductors, if you believe the results, which there are obviously some who don't.
Would you like your chakras realigned?
Re: Superconductivity fight
Our lecturer had just written a textbook on superconductivity in which he wrote that he'd left the chapter on high-Tc until last in the hope that someone would have figured out how it worked by the time he got around to it. That was also back in the 90's.Grumble wrote: ↑Thu Mar 17, 2022 4:17 pmThe temperature of superconductivity was a hot topic back in the 90’s when I was learning about it. Terrible straight-line extrapolation from essentially 2 groups of data points to show how it was all but inevitable that we would get room temperature superconductivity sometime soon. Motivated reasoning in abundance.shpalman wrote: ↑Thu Mar 17, 2022 9:00 amPreprint server removes ‘inflammatory’ papers in superconductor controversy
This is about that business of high-pressure room-temperature superconductors (i.e. "we got them to work at room temperature we only need a huge pressure to do it") as opposed to normal-'pressure low-temperature superconductors (i.e. "we got them to work at normal pressure we only need a low temperature to do it"). The low temperature is probably easier but yeah, room-temperature superconductors, if you believe the results, which there are obviously some who don't.
molto tricky
Re: Superconductivity fight
Really high temperature superconductivity would be fantastic for fusion power...shpalman wrote: ↑Thu Mar 17, 2022 4:21 pmOur lecturer had just written a textbook on superconductivity in which he wrote that he'd left the chapter on high-Tc until last in the hope that someone would have figured out how it worked by the time he got around to it. That was also back in the 90's.Grumble wrote: ↑Thu Mar 17, 2022 4:17 pmThe temperature of superconductivity was a hot topic back in the 90’s when I was learning about it. Terrible straight-line extrapolation from essentially 2 groups of data points to show how it was all but inevitable that we would get room temperature superconductivity sometime soon. Motivated reasoning in abundance.shpalman wrote: ↑Thu Mar 17, 2022 9:00 amPreprint server removes ‘inflammatory’ papers in superconductor controversy
This is about that business of high-pressure room-temperature superconductors (i.e. "we got them to work at room temperature we only need a huge pressure to do it") as opposed to normal-'pressure low-temperature superconductors (i.e. "we got them to work at normal pressure we only need a low temperature to do it"). The low temperature is probably easier but yeah, room-temperature superconductors, if you believe the results, which there are obviously some who don't.
