UK government plans an "official history" of the Troubles
Posted: Mon Nov 15, 2021 12:25 pm
The Sunday Telegraph has reported on the plans of Brandon Lewis, the Northern Ireland Secretary, to publish an "official history" of the Troubles. The print version of the story can be seen here (transcribed behind the spoiler below) and the online version can be seen here (there are minor differences between them).
Spoiler:
The Irish Daily Mail published an article today on the announcement (screenshot here, transcribed behind spoiler below).
Spoiler:
While the government is comparing this report to the one produced after WW1 (which seems to be held in high regard by historians) there is an overwhelming sense of cynicism from everyone who isn't directly involved in this plan. The fact it is being commissioned to "correct" a narrative has, I think, got many people worried that despite the promises of independence, there will be a narrative bias. The lack of discussion with the Irish or Northern Irish governments prior to the announcement also lends weight to fears that this will be a one-sided account that downplays the culpability of the British government and military.
The promises of no government interference also ring hollow when you remember how roundly the National Trust was attacked by Conservative MPs for publishing its Interim Report on the Connections between Colonialism and Properties now in the Care of the National Trust, which led to the formation of the Common Sense Group of over 50 Conservative MPs which then attacked its findings, its authors and the National Trust for daring to have commissioned it. Additionally,
Spoiler:
The Irish Daily Mail published an article today on the announcement (screenshot here, transcribed behind spoiler below).
Spoiler:
While the government is comparing this report to the one produced after WW1 (which seems to be held in high regard by historians) there is an overwhelming sense of cynicism from everyone who isn't directly involved in this plan. The fact it is being commissioned to "correct" a narrative has, I think, got many people worried that despite the promises of independence, there will be a narrative bias. The lack of discussion with the Irish or Northern Irish governments prior to the announcement also lends weight to fears that this will be a one-sided account that downplays the culpability of the British government and military.
The promises of no government interference also ring hollow when you remember how roundly the National Trust was attacked by Conservative MPs for publishing its Interim Report on the Connections between Colonialism and Properties now in the Care of the National Trust, which led to the formation of the Common Sense Group of over 50 Conservative MPs which then attacked its findings, its authors and the National Trust for daring to have commissioned it. Additionally,
If one minor report can do all that can you imagine what would happen if the Troubles report came out with anything less than a glowing account of the period on the part of British activities?Parliamentarians then called two debates in Parliamentary Hall and the House of Lords to debate the future of the National Trust (November) and the trust’s 125th anniversary (December), where the report was debated extensively. [Source]