https://angry-chef.com/blog/empathy
Although this is a departure from his usual material, like the good skeptic he is, there's also a bit of debunking:
I'm wondering about the 4 stages of empathy that he describes.As you are dozing through the Power Point slides, you may spot one claiming that only 7% of our communication is achieved through the words we say, with 93% coming from non-verbal means such as body language (55%) and tone of voice (38%). At this point, if you want to get along in the corporate world, my top tip is to keep your f.cking mouth shut. Resist any temptation to jolt out of your stupor and call b.llsh.t, even though these often regurgitated ‘facts’ are arse-gravy of the highest order.
How do people who are racist, misogynist or trans/homophobic fit into this process? Clearly they're not all psychopaths but do they turn off their empathy in order to 'Other' people and discriminate against them? Prejudice is partly a learnt behaviour so are they learning to block/turn off empathy? Could this mean that people who struggle to display it can learn to?Empathy is best described as a four stage process, the first of which is an ability to notice someone is having an emotional reaction. The second stage requires the observer to correctly interpret that reaction, translating the words, facial expressions, body language and vocalisations they are seeing into a defined emotional state.
The third stage requires deeper and more complex thought processes, and is probably what most people think constitutes genuine empathy. Here, the observer places themselves into the mind of the subject and attempts to feel what they are going through, seeing the world from their perspective. Then, at stage four, the observer tries to react appropriately based on what they have seen and experienced.
Stage three is the only one that is unique to someone feeling genuine empathy for another human. Psychopaths are generally characterised by a lack of empathy, but tend to be highly capable of all the other stages, although at stage 4 they will often only react if it benefits them to do so. Stage three is also by far the hardest component of empathy to define and measure, being completely internal and private.
As someone who has to do a bit of this, I find camouflaging interesting. I do know the appropriate way to respond, I just have to remind myself to do it very often. It feels like there's a bit in my brain that's not connected automatically and has to be manually turned on (as it were). I'm not on the spectrum, just not quite like other people in some regards. Or possibly a psychopath.
To get by in such a surface obsessed world, the only sensible strategy is to try and fake it. Pretend to react as people expect, spending years training your body and face to contort in ways that are completely unnatural. This is an astonishingly difficult thing to do, making the majority of social interactions terrifying and exhausting. Yet this camouflaging is something that seventy percent of autistic adults report doing most of the time, often resulting in huge damage to their physical and mental health